VOICES Voices Icon Ideas and Insight From Explorers


Ask Your Weird Animal Questions: Purple Frogs, Taming Zebras

I have always wondered why we have not domesticated [zebras] for riding, like horses? —CeeCee Hall, California

Historically, it’s a matter of circumstance that zebras weren’t domesticated—not necessarily because the equines are aggressive, as is commonly thought, said Fiona Marshall, an expert in animal domestication at Washington University in St. Louis. (See “Zebra Stripes Evolved to Repel Bloodsuckers?“)

Photo of 2 Grevy zebras.
Grevy’s zebras (Equus grevyi) in Maasai Mara National Reserve, Kenya. Photograph by Ivan Vdovin, AWL Images/Corbis

That’s because the three modern species of zebra—Grevy’s zebra, plains zebra, and mountain zebra—”weren’t in the right place at the right time,” Marshall said, while the African wild ass, the ancestor to the donkey, was. (There are no native horse species on the African continent.)

Asses were domesticated 7,000 to 8,000 years ago, when the Sahara began to turn to desert.

As the environment got drier, cattle herders “started moving, and it was an advantage to have an animal [like an ass] to put their belongings on so you could move whole families at one time.”

Marshall hypothesizes that wild asses benefited from staying near the cattle herders as conditions became increasingly dry. Zebra were not living in the region during this time of domestication.

The African wild ass is also a social animal that will breed in captivity, qualities thought to help make animals able to be domesticated.

These days, though, it is possible to domesticate zebras, she added. (See more of Marshall’s research and watch a video of African wild ass foals born at the St. Louis Zoo.)

What … insect looks like a spider but has six legs and two antenna, a small size, [and is] black in color? —Marge, Mississauga, Ontario

Phillip Koehler, an entomologist at the University of Florida in Gainesville, has a possible answer: “This time of year in Canada, it might be marmorated stink bugs. They look like spiderlings,” Koehler said via email.

Photo of a stink bug.
A brown marmorated stink bug in Maryland’s Patapsco River Valley. Photograph by George Grall, National Geographic

“Homeowners may not be familiar with them,” he said. The CBC reports that the stink bugs are an invasive species accidentally introduced to North America in the 1990s. The first official sighting in Ontario was in 2012.

According to Canadian news agency Global News, the bug has a stink defense that makes it smell like rotten coriander. (Related: “5 Animals With Stinky Defenses.”)

How can it be determined that the [Indian purple frogs, formally discovered in 2003] are an endangered species based on such a short time frame to study their population and habitat? —JohnFLob, NC

Sometimes it seems like the minute we hear about a new species it’s already declared endangered, but many factors go into assessing the risk of extinction.

“We’re not just looking at the species in isolation—we look at what’s going on with a species and where it lives,” said Ariadne Angulo of the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Red List of Threatened Species, which keeps track of how many species are doing worldwide.

For example, the Western Ghats, where the purple frog lives, is known for species that thrive only in that particular place—like koalas in Australia or lemurs in Madagascar. So if a species is found in only one habitat—especially if that habitat is threatened—it would be considered more vulnerable to extinction. (See National Geographic’s Last of the Last series on endangered species.)

Angulo says another factor is that it takes a long time to formally describe a species, so just because it’s formally announced doesn’t mean that people haven’t known about it.

“It may be that that researcher has been working on that species for five or ten years,” Angulo said.

How do fish check the safety of their environment? The fish I have observed surface, touching the water line with their nostrils, and go down to the bottom to find out if the water level is enough for their safety. —Ali, Shiraz, Iran

Adam Summers, a fish expert at the University of Washington, Seattle, said via email that fish have highly sensitive lines that run the length of their bodies and give them information about their environment.

The animals may surface and go back down for many reasons, but sensing depth isn’t one of them, he added. (See “How Do Glowing Sharks See in the Dark? New Surprises Revealed.”)

In terms of keeping safe, many fish smell predators, and some secrete an alarm substance when they are maltreated.

“Fishes nearby, with the ability to sense this schreckstoff”—which means “scary stuff” in German—”will hide when there is evidence of evil afoot,” Summers said.

Got a question about the weird and wild animal world? Tweet me or leave me a note on Facebook. 


  1. Amy
    Fort Myers Florida
    October 4, 2016, 11:11 pm

    I feed some stray cats for years. This year some frogs arrive to the cats feeding ground with the cats. To my suprise they are there daily and eat both wet and dry cat food and ineof the frogs eats outofmy hand. is itnormal fir all these. Frogs to eat wet and dry cat food? And today, although there are no lightning bugs around,i saw these frog’s butts could light up like lightning bugs! Am i hallucinatung?

  2. Liz Langley
    August 20, 2014, 5:49 pm

    Thank YOU @Nicolas and @sharon straughn – I appreciate the questions and am glad you’re enjoying the column and NatGeo. You make my day!

  3. sharon straughn
    louisville k.y.
    August 20, 2014, 3:58 pm

    I LOVE National Geographic magazine, NATGEO and NATGEOWILD t.v. channels, this web site,(weird animal questions, newswatch, and the weird and wild posts) along with the pictures of the day.Always interesting subjects that teach about nature and places. 🙂

  4. Nicolas
    August 20, 2014, 8:35 am

    Thanks so much guys! 🙂

  5. Liz Langley
    August 15, 2014, 3:08 pm

    @Henry T. Paiste, III
    Thanks, Henry! Much appreciated – look forward to finding the answers to any Weird Animal Questions you have! 🙂

  6. Liz Langley
    August 15, 2014, 3:07 pm

    Hi Nicholas! Christine is right – I emailed Fiona Marshall to get some more info on your question and she said that there were no plains or Grevy’s zebras in the Saharan grasslands where the cattle herders who domesticated the wild ass lived. She also says “Domestication is the outcome of a close (mutualistic) relationship that drew humans and animals together and occurred only rarely world-wide. We think that the particular factors that drew people and equids together in Africa was the drying of the Sahara. Climate change was less severe in eastern Africa and people focused on hunting and gathering until herders moved in from the Sahara, influencing local people and spreading their way of life 5000-4000 years ago.”

    Hope that helps!

  7. Liz Langley
    August 15, 2014, 2:52 pm

    Hi Tammy! Thanks for the question – to find out if a species is endangered check the IUCN Redlist of Threatened Species: http://www.iucnredlist.org/

  8. Henry T. Paiste, III
    August 14, 2014, 2:21 pm

    Yes.. I have been lucky to have read the Geographic almost every month – since SIXTH GRADE= (HAVERFORD SCHOOL) PA… AND even had magazine publishing experience with a major Publishing House… with our
    friends at TIME,INC. (NYC- CORP. MARKETING).. I just want to
    THANK YOU and all of your Staffers – WHAT A WONDERFUL
    ASSET – THE GEOGRAPHIC – to ” kids of all ages ” ! This
    new feature looks like an even newer attempt to give the
    very best each month. THANKS TO ALL – you are certainly
    appreciated !!
    Henry T. Paiste, III

  9. Nicolas
    Crested Butte, CO
    August 11, 2014, 4:49 pm

    My understanding was that zebras are in fact native to the African continent, however the horse-like form evolved in North America prior to movement across the Bering land bridge. This does not explain why humans wouldn’t have domesticated zebras, as zebras would have still been present. Do you mean that zebras occupied a range distant from that of humans within Africa during this Onager domestication era?

    • Christine Dell'Amore
      August 14, 2014, 10:52 pm

      Thanks for the comment, Nicholas. Yes, zebras were not living in that region during the wild ass domestication period. I added a sentence to make it more clear. Thanks, Christine (Weird & Wild editor)

    August 9, 2014, 4:20 pm

    I wanted to know how you know, when animals are endangered? That’s what I opened for.